Web Site Evaluation Rubric
By James Ditmore
Explanation of Rubric: Each of the criteria is worth 1 pt. toward the maximum possible 10 pts.
|
Unacceptable |
Weak |
Acceptable |
Good | Strong |
Exceptional |
|
| 1)There is a clear navigational structure with appropriate and effective options for exploration. | 0 pts. | .2 pt. | .4 pt. | .6 pt. | .8 pt. | 1 pt. |
| 2)Page Length is appropriate for intended audience. | 0 pts. | .2 pt. | .4 pt. | .6 pt. | .8 pt. | 1 pt. |
| 3)Graphics fit the usability of the Web site without distracting from it.. | 0 pts. | .2 pt. | .4 pt. | .6 pt. | .8 pt. | 1 pt. |
| 4)Overall design of the web site has contrast and repetition. | 0 pts. | .2 pt. | .4 pt. | .6 pt. | .8 pt. | 1 pt. |
| 5)Offers consistent account of
Learning activities (including specific examples). |
0 pts. | .2 pt. | .4 pt. | .6 pt. | .8 pt. | 1 pt. |
| 6)Expectations (as to similar design and different content) continue as the user browses the web site. | 0 pts. | .2 pt. | .4 pt. | .6 pt. | .8 pt. | 1 pt. |
| 7)All images, links, bookmarks, etc. function. | 0 pts. | .2 pt. | .4 pt. | .6 pt. | .8 pt. | 1 pt. |
| 8)Site design reflects web design principles (Appropriateness, Placement, Consistency, and Usability). | 0 pts. | .2 pt. | .4 pt. | .6 pt. | .8 pt. | 1 pt. |
| 9)All outside sources are cited appropriately. | 0 pts. | .2 pt. | .4 pt. | .6 pt. | .8 pt. | 1 pt. |
| 10)Student Assessment is within 20% of Instructor's Assessment | 0 pts. | .2 pt. | .4 pt. | .6 pt. | .8 pt. | 1 pt. |
Source: This Rubric is a
modified version of that created by
Jeanne Po,
jeanne.po.1@bc.edu March 12, 2000
You can find the original version at her web site:
http://www2.bc.edu/~poje/ed367/midterm/rubric.html