MASTER TECHNOLOGY TEACHER CERTIFICATION PROGRAM
- Education Service Center
- Region XI
|
 |

|
 |
 |
 |
|
Charmaine C. Bentley
|
|
|
|
 |
Assessment Instruments
|
Mentor:
Charmaine Bentley
|
Coach:
Patti Flanary |
Mentee:
Debra Graham |
|
This is a collaborative
lesson (between English III Teacher and
Media Specialist) where the Media Specialist
will be guiding English III students in a
series of activities related to the works of
Edgar Allen Poe (short stories). English III
TEKS are specifically targeted and one of
the anticipated results in enhanced
performance on the TAKS (and other
standardized examinations such as the SAT2,
etc.). Students will work individually and
in small groups in the library, classroom,
"Typing Lab", as well as home, etc.,
to create a various products related to the
targeted objectives. Assuming the lesson is
successful, the media specialist expects to
expand this approach to other teachers
(first in language arts, then Social
Studies, Science, and ...).
|
|
|
Formal and Informal
Assessment Feedback Plan
|
Continuous/frequent feedback between you and
the students
Formal
Journal
Electronic
checklist
Group
Evaluations
Product
Evaluations
Informal
Discussion
Peer
feedback
Observation
Encouragement
for students to reflect on their learning
progress and achievement
Formal
Electronic
checklist
Informal
Discussion
Self-assessment
Peer
feedback
Determination
of students' learning progress and
achievement
Formal
Journal
evaluations (grades)
Electronic
checklist (grades)
Group
evaluations (grades)
Product
evaluations (grades}
Informal
Discussion
Self-assessment
Peer
feedback
Observation
|
|
Assessment Strategies
|
|
Goals |
Sub-Goals
(Objectives) |
Type of
Learning |
Assessment Strategies |
Feedback
Strategy |
1. Use prewriting strategies to generate
ideas, develop voice, and plan; develop
drafts both alone and collaboratively by
organizing and reorganizing content and by
refining style to suit occasion, audience,
and purpose; proofread writing for
appropriateness of organization, content,
style, and conventions; frequently refine
selected pieces to publish for general and
specific audiences; and use technology for
aspects of creating, revising, editing,
and publishing texts (TEKS 110.44.b.2.A-E)
|
a. Journal using word
processor using designated filename and
saving on A:/ Drive.
b. Brainstorm to develop ideas including
required standards for evaluation.
c. Observe and maintain a time line to
complete project using electronic
checklist.
d. Use provided templates to produce
required products.
e. Use appropriate software, brainstorm,
organize, develop drafts, proof, revise,
refine, and publish information.
f. Use appropriate strategies to prepare
“successful” presentation.
|
Cognitive
-
Knowledge
-
Comprehension
-
Application
-
Analysis
-
Synthesis
-
Evaluation
Psychomotor
-
Acquiring knowledge
-
Executing actions
-
Transfer of control
-
Automization
-
Generation
Affective
|
a. Journals
b. Student self-assessment and peer
review
c. Teacher evaluation and student
self-assessment
d. Completed product using provided
templates
e. Student self-assessment, peer
review, and completed products
f. Student self-assessment, peer
review, and completed products
|
a. Inclusion in final product -
compilation of journal entries
b. Peer feedback, inclusion of
suggestions into evaluation rubrics
c. Peer feedback, progress reports
(automated - spreadsheet)
d. Graded work
e. Peer feedback, graded work
(product grades)
f. Peer feedback, graded work
(product grades)
|
2. Read to be entertained, to appreciate
a writer's craft, to be informed, to take
action, and to discover models to use in
his/her own writing; read American and
other world literature, including classic
and contemporary works; and interpret the
possible influences of the historical
context on literary works. (TEKS
110.44.b.8.A,B,D)
|
a. Select and read poem or
short story written by Edgar Allen Poe.
b. Research environment/ history related
to origin of short story/poem - formulate
questions to ask, use available resources
(library, Internet), and organize.
c. Use selection to complete stylistic
analysis (using provided template).
d. Use analysis to write
short story or poem in
consistent style
or create related product.
|
Cognitive
-
Knowledge
-
Comprehension
-
Application
-
Analysis
-
Synthesis
-
Evaluation
Psychomotor
-
Acquiring knowledge
-
Executing actions
-
Transfer of control
-
Automization
-
Generation
Affective
|
a. Student self-assessment and peer
review
b. Student self-assessment and peer
review
c. Completed product using provided
templates
d. Student self-assessment, peer
review, and completed products
|
a. Peer feedback
b. Peer feedback and success of
attempted research strategies
c. Graded work
d. Peer feedback, graded work
(product grades)
|
3. Recognize distinctive
and shared characteristics of cultures
through reading; and compare text events
with his/her own and other readers'
experiences. (TEKS 110.44.b.9.A,B)
|
a. With aid of template
(spreadsheet), use research of
environment/ time/ origin of short story/
poem to relate to student’s environment/
time/ origin.
b. Using research, compare/contrast
environment/ time/ origin of short story/
poem to student’s environment/ time/
origin.
|
Cognitive
-
Knowledge
-
Comprehension
-
Application
-
Analysis
-
Synthesis
-
Evaluation
Psychomotor
-
Acquiring knowledge
-
Executing actions
-
Transfer of control
-
Automization
-
Generation
Affective
|
a. Student self-assessment, peer
review, and completed product
b. Student self-assessment, peer
review, and completed products
|
a. Peer feedback, graded work (product
grades)
b. Peer feedback and success
of attempted research strategies,
graded work (product grades)
|
4. Connect literature to historical
contexts, current events, and his/her own
experiences; (TEKS 110.44.b.11.E)
|
a. With aid of template
(spreadsheet), use research of
environment/ time/ origin of short story/
poem to relate to student’s environment/
time/ origin.
b. Use recognized relations
(and provided/ completed templates)
to complete poem/ short story/ rap/
other product
in related style using student’s
experiences for context.
|
Cognitive
-
Knowledge
-
Comprehension
-
Application
-
Analysis
-
Synthesis
-
Evaluation
Psychomotor
-
Acquiring knowledge
-
Executing actions
-
Transfer of control
-
Automization
-
Generation
Affective
|
a. Student self-assessment, peer
review, and completed product using
provided templates
b. Student self-assessment, peer
review, and completed product using
provided templates
|
a. Peer feedback, graded work (product
grades)
b. Peer feedback, graded work
(product grades)
|
5. Evaluate the credibility
of information sources, including how the
writer's motivation may affect that
credibility; (TEKS 110.44.b.12.B)
|
a. Evaluate reliability of resource
material and source.
b. Determine which information sources to
use for project’s purposes.
|
Cognitive
-
Knowledge
-
Comprehension
-
Application
-
Analysis
-
Synthesis
-
Evaluation
Psychomotor
-
Acquiring knowledge
-
Executing actions
-
Transfer of control
-
Automization
-
Generation
Affective
|
a. Student self-assessment, peer
review, and completed product
b. Student self-assessment, peer
review, and completed product
|
a. Peer feedback, graded work (product
grades)
b. Peer feedback, graded work
(product grades)
|
6. Generate relevant,
interesting, and researchable questions;
locate appropriate print and non-print
information using text and technical
resources, including databases and the
Internet; use text organizers such as
overviews, headings, and graphic features
to locate and categorize information;
produce reports and research projects in
varying forms for audiences; and draw
conclusions from information gathered. (TEKS
110.44.b.13.A-E)
|
a. Develop “relevant,
interesting, and researchable” questions
to research short story or poem and its
environment of origin. (Where was Poe at
time of story and what was happening to
him and around him?)
b. Organize elements
relating story/ poem to environment/
origin using concept mapping and templates
if available.
c. Draw conclusions
regarding relationship of elements of
story/ poem to environment/ origin.
d. Present information regarding elements
and their relationship using appropriate
software (word processor/ presentation/
spreadsheet/ video).
|
Cognitive
-
Knowledge
-
Comprehension
-
Application
-
Analysis
-
Synthesis
-
Evaluation
Psychomotor
-
Acquiring knowledge
-
Executing actions
-
Transfer of control
-
Automization
-
Generation
Affective
|
a. Student self-assessment, peer
review, and completed product
b. Student self-assessment, peer
review, and completed product
c. Student self-assessment, peer
review, and completed product
d. Student self-assessment, peer
review, and completed product
|
a. Peer feedback and success of
attempted research strategies, graded
work (product grades)
b. Peer feedback, graded work
(product grades)
c. Peer feedback, graded work
(product grades)
d. Peer feedback, graded work
(product grades)
|
7. Use the conventions of
oral language effectively; use informal,
standard, and technical language
effectively to meet the needs of purpose,
audience, occasion, and task; communicate
effectively in conversations and group
discussions while problem solving, and
planning; use effective verbal and
nonverbal strategies in presenting oral
messages; ask clear questions for a
variety of purposes and respond
appropriately to the questions of others;
and make relevant contributions in
conversations and discussions. (TEKS
110.44.b.15.A-F)
|
a. Work in small groups to research
background information for short story/
poem.
b. Work in small groups to produce product
to present background information for
short story/ poem.
c. Work in small groups to produce short
story/ poem/ rap/ skit/ narration/
etc. that represents group’s
interpretation of updated version of short
story or poem.
|
Cognitive
-
Knowledge
-
Comprehension
-
Application
-
Analysis
-
Synthesis
-
Evaluation
Psychomotor
-
Acquiring knowledge
-
Executing actions
-
Transfer of control
-
Automization
-
Generation
Affective
|
a. Student self-assessment, peer
review, and completed product
b. Student self-assessment, peer
review, and completed product
c. Student self-assessment, peer
review, and completed product
|
a. Peer feedback and success of
attempted research strategies, graded
work (product grades)
b. Peer feedback, graded work
(product grades)
c. Peer feedback, graded work
(product grades)
|
8. Present interpretations
such as telling stories, performing
original works, and interpreting poems and
stories for a variety of audiences. (TEKS
110.44.b.18.C)
|
a. Provide background
presentation for short story/ poem/ rap/
other product using
appropriate medium.
b. publish short story/ poem/ rap/ etc.
using appropriate medium.
|
Cognitive
-
Knowledge
-
Comprehension
-
Application
-
Analysis
-
Synthesis
-
Evaluation
Psychomotor
-
Acquiring knowledge
-
Executing actions
-
Transfer of control
-
Automization
-
Generation
Affective
|
a. Student self-assessment, peer
review, and completed product
b. Student self-assessment, peer
review, and completed product
|
a. Peer feedback, graded work (product
grades)
b. Peer feedback, graded work
(product grades)
|
|
|
Rubrics
|
Group
|
Journal
|
Project
|
Group
|
Points
|
0 - 2 |
3 - 5 |
6 - 8 |
9 - 11 |
Participation
|
Does not engage in activities
|
Rarely engages in activities
|
Engaged in most activities
|
Engaged in all activities
|
Cooperation
|
Never ready to contribute or to
support team effort
|
Rarely ready
to contribute
or support
team effort
|
Usually ready to contribute and
supports team effort
|
Always ready to contribute
and support team effort
|
Responsibility
|
Cannot be depended upon in performance
of duties
|
Rarely dependable in performance of
duties
|
Usually is dependable in
performance of duties
|
Always dependable in
performance of duties
|
Quantity of Work
|
Much less than
proportional share
|
Less than proportional share
|
More than proportional share
|
Much more than proportional
share
|
Quality of Work
|
Inadequate
|
Barely satisfactory
|
Good
|
Excellent
|
|
Journal
|
Points
|
0 - 2 |
3 - 5 |
6 - 8 |
9 - 11 |
Journal Entries
|
Not present
|
Most are present but not all and/or
entries for the most part are unclear,
inappropriate, or incomplete
|
Recorded daily
but are not
always clear,
appropriate, or
complete
|
Recorded daily and are clear,
appropriate, and complete
|
Conventions
|
No apparent paragraphing. Both grammar
and punctuation errors are common
|
Paragraphing is confusing. Grammar or
punctuation errors are common.
|
Paragraphing intentional, with one
main idea. One or two errors with
grammar or punctuation
|
Paragraphing intentional, assisting
the reader, with one main idea.
Correct grammar and punctuation.
|
Fluency
|
Meaning is unintelligible or
confusing. Run-ons are common or
sentences are incomplete.
|
Meaning of sentences is unclear. Only
one or two run-ons or incomplete
sentences
|
Meaning of sentences is clear with no
run-ons or incomplete sentences
|
Sentences begin in varied manner and
length with sentences building on the
ones that came before
|
Organization
|
Ideas not organized in meaningful
manner
|
Logical connectors used, but
organization does not reflect a
logical sequence
|
Ideas flow and
are well
connected with
appropriate
introduction
|
Ideas organized in a meaningful way,
reflecting a logical sequence
|
|
Project (Solution)
|
Points
|
0 - 2 |
3 - 5 |
6 - 8 |
9 - 11 |
Success in
Targeting
Objective(s)
|
Almost none of the targeted objectives
are achieved
|
Few of the targeted objectives are
achieved
|
Most of the targeted objectives are
achieved
|
All of the targeted objectives are
achieved
|
Coverage of
Criteria
|
Very little if any of background
information provided is appropriately
covered
|
Little of the background information/
requirements provided is appropriately
covered
|
Most to all of
the
background
information or
requirements
covered
appropriately
|
The required criteria are covered in a
manner that goes above and beyond what
was required
|
Organization
of Content
and
Mechanics
|
No apparent connection or
relation among items. Extensive
spelling and grammatical errors
|
Connections and relations between
items stated difficult to grasp. Few
spelling or grammatical errors
|
Connections and relations between
items are apparent. Almost no spelling
or grammatical errors
|
Connections and relations are clear,
direct, and add to the solution
(project) No spelling or grammatical
errors
|
Originality
|
Minimal rehash of others’ ideas
|
Large
collection of
ideas that
have
belonged to
others
|
Others' ideas have been altered,
modified, and improved
|
Most of the ideas presented are
original and inventive
|
Subject
Knowledge
|
Knowledge of subject not evident
|
Knowledge of subject demonstrated at
minimal level
| | | |